Timmy is in class, when he meets Chloe Carmichael who is his new neighbor. He must share his fairies with her, because of a fairy godparent shortage. She wishes everyone in Dimmsdale would share everything, causing chaos.
The episode begins outside Dimmsdale Elementary School where Timmy uses a robot as a decoy. Timmy gets in the suit and Cosmo pushes a button causing it to dance. Once Timmy in the suit is inside the school, Mr. Crocker starts Crocker doing a Denzel Crocker Show and introduces a new student, Chloe Carmichael. It shows that she is smart according to a clip. She saved a monster from destroying a city. Timmy gets out of the robot suit. Timmy is starting to get jealous of Chloe. Chloe finds out that there wasn't suppose to be school and so school is dismissed. Timmy don't want to be friends with Chloe. Timmy mentions that Chloe don't have Fairy Godparents and finds out she is Timmy's new neighbor. Chloe's House is next to Timmy's house. Mr. and Mrs. Turner are big fans of Chloe. Timmy goes to his bedroom. Timmy mentions again that he has one thing that Chloe doesn't have: Fairy Godparnets!
When Timmy still have fairies, Jorgen appeared who was very happy and joyfully tell Timmy that his fairies are no longer all his. Much to Timmy and the others surprised, Jorgen explains about fairy godparent shortage because of highly demands. Timmy has to share his fairies with Chloe. Timmy don't like sharing and Timmy has a hard time saying the word "share." Timmy screams "no" nonstop for 47 hours. Chloe needs fairies because she is not always prefect. Chloe thinks she is dreaming but she isn't. Chloe goes in the closet to scream "yes" all night until the next day. Timmy wishes to be far away as possible which is the center of Earth which cotain mole people. Timmy gets out through a sewer drain in Dimmisdale. Timmy wishes that Friday wasn't a thing anymore. Foop appears and causes choas. Every Friday, The Big Wand gets recharged and with Friday gone, it doesn't get recharged. The Big Wand power is designed to prevent Anti-Fairies from causing chaos. Jorgen appears and brings back Friday. Everything is back to normal.
Timmy wishes for a bot and the bot gives him a bath. Chloe makes her first wish and she wishes for everyone to share which eventually causes choas. Timmy tries to unwish it but can't because godkids can't unwish other godkid's wish. Chloe admits defeat and unwishes things to be back normal. Someone steals a fire hydrant causing the hole to spray Cosmo and Wanda and making them lose their wands before they could grant the wish. A crack forms and the mole people comes out. Chloe reveals that she isn't always prefect and that why she was given fairies. She shows a clip about when she saved the monster, the monster ended up destorying the city.Chloe don't have many friends. Timmy and Chloe becomes friends. Timmy falls into the crack and Chloe rescues him. Timmy gets the wand and Chloe everything to the way it was before the wish was made. They poof to far back to the dinosaur times. Chloe says the wish more specific and everything is back to normal before her wish was made. Chloe says she was done with fairies but Timmy decides that he will share. The episode ends with Chloe, Timmy, Cosmo and Wanda doing duck lips selfie. Mr. Turner appears too with lip sticks and wondering who used them.