Scary GodCouple is the tenth episode of Season 9.
Foop becomes Vicky's anti-fairy godparent. Vicky and Foop terrorize Timmy and the kids of Dimmsdale. Foop tells Vicky that the reason Timmy has thwarted her all these years is because he has fairy godparents. If they can destroy the fairies, no one will be able to stop them.
The episode starts with Foop alongside the Anti-Fairy Council deciding on who Foop will become a scary godparent to. They show Vicky, which scares Foop. He has to do it according to them, because otherwise, his baba will zap him. Meanwhile, Timmy, Cosmo, Wanda, Poof and Sparky are at a beach that Timmy poofed up. However, Vicky comes in and Timmy has to poof it away. Vicky then sends in a rabid badger to attack Timmy and states that they won't go to the circus! She then leaves to go watch her show.
Cosmo distracts the badger. Then, Timmy wishes up a circus in his room because of what Vicky did. The plan goes well until Vicky when an elephant lands on her and she immediately suspects Timmy of something. She goes upstairs to see what is going on and sees the circus but gets hit by some hot food. Vicky tells Mr. Turner that Timmy had a circus upstairs but when they go upstairs, they just see Timmy reading a comic book with Sparky asleep on the bed and Timmy's god parents in the fishbowl. Mr. Turner thinks that Vicky is delusional then leaves.
Vicky then goes outside, annoyed at the fact that Mr. Turner didn't believe her. Foop then comes and says that he has to be her scary godparent and to grant her every wish. Vicky's first wish is to make Foop have boy band hair. Vicky's second wish is to chain Dinkleberg to Mr. Turner for not paying her! Mr. Turner is annoyed that he is chained to Dinkleberg. Then, she wishes to make everyone miserable and the way she does it is by forcing everyone to practice their tuba. Chet Ubetcha announces that strange things have been happening like how the tuba is attacking the others for not practicing.
Timmy alongside Sparky, Cosmo, Wanda and Poof think that it's weird that these things are going on. Then, Timmy uses Cosmo, Wanda and Poof's magic to poof the tubas away, angering Vicky who then threatens Foop! Foop is starting to get a little annoyed. Vicky then wishes the children of Dimmsdale into lockers! Timmy uses Cosmo Wanda and Poof to poof the lockers away. Vicky then gets even angrier! Foop also sees that there's a bunch of fruit bats in Vicky's place, creeping him out. Then, Vicky tries to get kids miserable even more which is only stopped by Timmy.
Vicky then asks Foop why her stuff is being undone and she also locks Foop in a locker for spitting gum in her hair. Foop responds that it's Timmy's fairy godparents who has been stopping her this whole time. Vicky then gets very angry at that and asks Foop how to stop them. Foop says that he isn't an expert but knows one. They then go to Crocker's house and Crocker shows them how to catch a fairy. Vicky fools Crocker into believing that he can help them and once she figures out that the fairies like rump roast, she gets his rump roast machine. Then, Crocker said since they are going fairy hunting, he's going to go with them. Vicky uses Foop's magic to lock Crocker in a locker.
Meanwhile, Mr. Turner, still chained to Dinkleberg, is watching baseball and is also on a cruise ship with Dinkleberg annoying him to no end. Back with Timmy, Poof, Sparky, Cosmo and Wanda try to figure out who is behind the mishaps that have been created. They then finally figure out that Vicky did it. However, before they can stop her, Cosmo, Wanda and Poof smell the rump roast and thus get attracted to it. They then get trapped by Vicky and Foop, Vicky planning on vaporizing Cosmo, Wanda and Poof!
Timmy asks Sparky why he wasn't attracted to it and he responds he doesn't like the stuff. Same goes for Foop when Vicky asks him. Foop stated that Anti-Faries' weakness is Chicken Cordon Bleu. Vicky then wishes that Timmy has to dance like a ballerina, taught by a monkey. Otherwise, he would get zapped by the monkey's Tazer.
Timmy askes if he can stop but the monkey just zaps him, annoying him. Vicky then uses Foop's magic to create monsters underneath kids beds, get rid of birthday parties and more things to make kids miserable and restore her other wishes. Vicky and Foop get away from Timmy and Sparky. Meanwhile, Sparky has to save the day, but not before hitting the paddle ball six times in a row. He then comes to Timmy's aid and uses his skills to defeat the monkey to get Timmy free. As well as this, the monkey slips on a banana peel, ironically. Then, Timmy and Sparky go over to where Foop and Vicky are.
Before they can break in, the tubacabra comes over to them and Timmy has to practice on the tuba before the tuba attacks them! He then does it but after that, he gets annoyed and slams his tuba on top of the tubacabra. Then, Timmy and Sparky break in. Vicky then forces Foop to wear a sandpaper diaper! Timmy, with a little trouble, convinces Foop to stop helping Vicky after he promises to get him Chicken Cordon Bleu and a new baba. Foop then zaps Vicky and Cosmo, Wanda and Poof are freed at the last second. Foop then gets the stuff he promised and undoes the wishes that were done.
One kid said that he was traumatized from the monsters underneath his bed. Then, Mr. Turner is no longer chained to Dinkleberg, which he is angrily thankful for and thus, he forces Dinkleberg to rub suntan lotion on his hairy back. Meanwhile with Foop, he wishes that the Anti-Fairy Council had sandpaper diapers as they itch a lot.
Cosmo, Timmy, Wanda, Poof and Sparky are glad that they are done with Vicky and Foop at least for now. Timmy asks Wanda where she poofed Vicky which Wanda responds, that it's under control. The episode ends with Vicky being forced to dance as a ballerina by the monkey with the tazer in a sandpaper tutu.