The episode starts at The Turner's House, in Timmy's Room, where Wanda, Timmy Turner, and Chloe Carmichael are all covered in feathers, Wanda shake the feathers from her body and scolds Timmy for visiting the evil chicken people, Timmy made an excuse to get off doing his homework, Cosmo appears with a giant egg to cook an omelet, only to hatch into an evil chicken that chases him, until Wanda poofs it away.
Then, Mr. Turner appears at the door and Cosmo and Wanda turned back to their goldfish form. He comes in with a tracksuit and his money, then he mistakes Timmy and Chloe for chickens because of their feathers, Timmy explains that it's him and Chloe, but his dad is still confused. Both of them shake off the feathers to reveal themselves to him.
Timmy's Dad now understands it's them, then he breaks into tears and sits on Timmy's bed and ask Timmy for his therapy puppet, much for the latter dismay, he asks what's going on and says being rich is getting him respect, but he spent his money on a tracksuit and a hovercraft, one of his neighbors complain it's on his lawn, Mr. Turner says it's above his lawn and calling him a stooge twice.
Chloe suggests to be not a jerk, Mr. Turner mistakes this for "jork", he asks both of them how "jorks" get respect, Chloe listed "Doctors, Teachers, and Humanitarians", while Timmy listed "Cage Fighters, Time Cops, and Sasquatch", Timmy's Dad says he'll be mayor, Mrs. Turner wants to be the first lady, but her husband denies that and leaves, Timmy's Mom also leaves.
Their fairies revert to their normal selves and Timmy doubts his father never be mayor, but Chloe suggests they can wish for him to be mayor, and grants their fairies to do it, his dad won, much for Timmy and Chloe excitement, then the house suddenly transformed to a mansion. Then the news and paparazzi appear at their house, with Chet Ubetcha reported this and the Mayor of Dimmsdale resign and fulfill his dream of transforming Chompy to a hip-hop artist. Timmy's Dad then get a tiara and a sash saying "Mayor".
Then Chet spotted Timmy and Chloe, then giving them tiaras and sashes that saying "Mayor Kid" and "Smarter Friend" respectively, Timmy Dad gives a 10,000 bounty (then 20,000) on Dinkleberg and force policemen to wear bunny suits, a reporter asks about the Dimmsdale Dam, he said, "Not my problem!", Timmy's Mom gets a tiara and sash that say "Mrs. Mayor", and declares when people see her, they say "Aoo Ga!" and make wolf noises, one person says his wife will throw him out, Mrs. Turner says "Not my problem!" and they do it anyway. Timmy says school has to be 5 minutes for recess, much for Chloe agony, but Timmy says "Not my problem". Both of them get dropped off at school.
They get attention from their classmates and paparazzi, Mr. Crocker then appears to his favorite student, claiming it's Timmy, not Chloe, much for the former and latter, delight and annoyance, respectively. He says Timmy's Dad control his budget, and his budget was short and gives Timmy an "A" on his book report, even though he never did it, Crocker did it for him. School ends and Crocker runs off saying he hates kids, much for Timmy and Chloe shock as they themselves are children. At home, Timmy's Dad demands orders to his "Yes Men", Timmy walks home and closes the door on the paparazzi, much for his irritation. Wanda suggests doing their original routine, make irresponsible wishes, Timmy wishes to be a sumo wrestler and Cosmo also be one, much for the latter amazement that he is wearing a diaper.
Then paparazzi appears and both fairies turned back to goldfish, Timmy says he needs their magic, but it's too late. The paparazzi take pictures of Timmy butt, much for his embarrassment. Then Chloe and the others read an article about "Mayor Kid's goes Cuckoo, dresses in diapers and yells at fish" and Chloe says that the first and last time she ever says that, Timmy saying that people think he's crazy and saw his butt, the four of them look through the window and then chaos happens.
Chloe is telling Timmy that his dad laws are making things worse, but the latter says "Not my problem!", and is irritated because people saw his butt and the former gets angry and say she has to do something, Chloe wishes that she can help police direct traffic, she leaves. A cameraman appears at Timmy window and he pushes the ladder off. Timmy wishes to be in the middle of nowhere, it's a desert and Timmy is really thirsty and asks for water. Cosmo poofs himself to be a toilet, much for Timmy's frustration, the paparazzi appear and take photos once again.
In a newspaper, people think Timmy is crazy again, Wanda suggests to un-wish the wish, but if he does, his dad will be devastated. More and more paparazzi appear and Timmy gets rid of them, Timmy has no other choice but to get rid of his fairies, which makes the three of them cry. His dad enters and sees his son crying and resigns as mayor, Timmy and his dad embraced each other, after he leaves, he and his fairies hugged and un-wished his wish, the paparazzi are gone and Chloe was safe from being hit by cars.
Later, Chloe, Timmy, Wanda, and Cosmo watch the aftermath on the news to see that the old mayor got his job back and Chompy won an award, Chloe said she is glad that Timmy's Dad was mayor, but Timmy was furious that people saw his butt, his dad comes in and their fairies reverted once again to their goldfish form, Mr. Turner says he can give respect by testing a hair formula called "Crazy Hair", he tested it and hair is grown all around his body.
As both children stare, he panics, saying his hair is crazy, and he falls out the window and landed on Timmy's Mom to break his fall and saying he's okay, much for Timmy and Chloe eccentric. Timmy smiles happily and says once again, "Not my problem!", much to Chloe's amusement. The episode ends.