This was Tootie's first appearance on the show since she was featured in one of the Oh Yeah! Cartoons shorts, she is wearing different clothes and more distinctive glasses. Her voice actress was also changed from Amber Wood to Grey DeLisle, the same voice actress as Vicky.
This is the only appearance of Tootie in Season 2.
The original title card had the Crimson Chin doll in a yellow box on a black background. It's unknown why it was changed, but it continues to be used in international airings, Nicktoons airings, and on the VHS and DVD of Superhero Spectacle.
This is the second time that Timmy has been shrunk magically. The first being in "Tiny Timmy!"
When AJ says that Chester, Timmy, and him were ten years old, this reveals that Chester and AJ were nine years old in the first season.
Both this episode and its partner's names have two words that rhyme.
In a PC game, "Wizard101," O'Leary is a type of enemy.
Hey Arnold - Tootie's Timmy shrine is similar to Helga Pataki's "Arnold shrine".
Crimson Chin Doll - "Justice, thy name is Chin!" - This is a take-off on Hamlet's line, "Frailty, thy name is woman".
Tootie: Do you, Timmy, take you, Tootie, to be your lawfully wedded WIFE!?
Vicky: Well, well, well. What's this, two new toys? Well guess who they get to meet!
Tootie: Not Mister Hammer.
Cosmo and Wanda: Mister Hammer!?
Vicky: Yes, Mister Hammer, and his friend, Mrs. Saw!
Cosmo: Hi Mrs. Saw, I'm Cosmo and this is Wanda.
(Wanda glared at him)
Cosmo: Don't you want to be a good host?
Tootie: Nooo! Those are Timmy's dolls!
(Vicky kicked Tootie in the face and held her off by the foot)
Vicky (sarcastically): Oh that changes everything!
(Vicky pulled out a blow torch)
Cosmo: Hey, Mister Fire! Have you met Wanda?
Timmy: Chew on your butt, not my friend!
(Timmy tipped over a glass of lemonade near Doidle and hid)
Vicky: What was that?
(Vicky let go of Tootie who crashed into a wall, and then went downstairs. She saw the puddle of yellow liquid near Doidle)
Vicky: Bad dog! You know you're only supposed to do that outside, or at Timmy's house!
Cosmo: C'mon Timmy, let's get your stupid doll and get out of here!
Timmy: He's not stupid, he's my friend, and I should have treated him better.
(Tootie ran into the kitchen. Timmy and his fairies hid)
Tootie: Nooo! Vicky's stolen Timmy's dolls! Now he'll never come over, and he'll never like me... WHY DOESN'T HE LIKE ME!?
(Tootie ran off into her living room and cried on the couch)
Wanda: Maybe he's not the only one you should treat better.
Cosmo: You know, she might be creepy, but she does have to put up with Vicky more than you do.
Timmy: Yeah, you're right. Vicky lives here. I guess when she's not torturing me at my house, she's torturing Tootie here. That's gotta be the worst.
Timmy: Actually, I just wanted to say, I'm sorry I was mean to you. I'm just...
Cosmo and Wanda dolls: A stupid ten year old boy!
Timmy: Right! And I'm not interested in girls, and I won't be until...
Cosmo and Wanda dolls: He's a stupid eleven year old boy!
Tootie: Then there's hope? THERE'S HOPE! (she jumped excitedly)
Crimson Chin doll: I'm totally into the idea of you giving me to Tootie. This way she can always have a little piece of you she can smother and choke with love.
Timmy: Wow, that was an oddly specific action phrase. I'm gonna miss you pal.
Crimson Chin doll: I put the MAN in mandible!
(Timmy handed the doll to Tootie)
Timmy: Tootie, I want you to have this doll. More importantly, I want you to have this doll and never, ever follow me home again.
Tootie: Oh Timmy, this is the best gift ever!
Timmy: And it can be our little secret... of LOVE!
(Timmy has wished the Crimson Chin doll indestructible and has 12000 "I hate Vicky" phrases. Vicky tries to melt it with a blow torch, but the toy remains intact.)
Crimson Chin doll: Your icky, red-headed yuckiness cannot pierce the shield of Tootie's love! (Vicky fires her blow torch again, but still to no avail) Evil redheads make boy bands say "EWWW!"
Vicky: Why won't this stupid toy BREAK!?
Wanda: That was really sweet of you, Timmy.
Timmy: Yeah well, as long as Chester and A.J. don't EVER find out me being nice to a girl, I'm safe.
Chester: Hey Timmy, look who's here...
Tootie: Timmy! Timmy! Over heeeeere! Come see what I made!
(Timmy looked out the window of his tree house only to see Chester and A.J. with Tootie.)
Tootie: Timmy, Tim-eeee! Look! (she pointed to Crimson Chin doll, now wearing a pink hat) this doll is you... (she pointed to a Tootie look-alike doll) and this doll is ME! MWAH MWAH MWAH! I love you Timmy! Mwah mwah mwah, I love you too Tootie! Mmmmwah! Mmmmwah! Oooh Timmy, I got you something too!
(Tootie threw a water balloon at Timmy and she, Chester, and A.J. laughed)
Timmy: You know what? Love stinks.
Cosmo: And it's wet, too!
Crimson Chin doll: Brush that cleft EVERY DAY!
Although this episode premiered in 2002, it was made in 2001 according to the credits.